True Biopic Vs Inspired by

This Diwali, Soorarai Pottru meaning ‘Praise the Brave’, a much awaited Tamil film finally reached the audience. With theatres barely opening up few days ago amidst myriad Covid restrictions, the makers took an early call to go for an exclusive OTT release instead of a mega theatrical release. The film is based or rather inspired by Capt. Gopinath’s book Simply Fly which is his autobiography. However it is not a true biopic on Captain Gopinath whose calling card has been that of being the pioneer of low cost Aviation in India. The book Simply Fly which I just quickly glanced through in the last couple of days traces his life as a diligent child to his brief stint with the forces and then turning an entrepreneur with Deccan Helicopters and finally achieving his dream of building an affordable airline for the masses by launching Air Deccan. In the book, he outlines the travails in this journey which is certainly inspiring.

Unlike films that are released in theatres where the reception could be gauged by the Box Office numbers, for OTT releases, one has to just go by the buzz the film creates in the media and in particular Social media. So by that gauge, one must say that Soorarai Pottru has opened to positive reviews from critics and a rousing welcome overall from general audience.  At the same time, it has also drawn a huge flak particularly on Social media.

The brickbats for the film are around the way Captain Gopinath’s role is portrayed which has triggered a social media storm, if I may say, in the tea cup. The major angst is over portraying the main protagonist character played by actor Suriya not as an upper caste Brahmin which Gopinath is. In the film, the character goes by the name Nedumaaran Rajangam and is shown as belonging to the under privileged class.  The question which has been raised is, why twist the facts while basing the story on a real life individual, Captain Gopinath in this case. What’s wrong in show casing the story of a struggling upper caste individual, is the follow up question.

Here’s the thing. A biopic by definition is a film that shows the life of a person typically a public or a famous figure. A biopic follows the true life of the individual and the screen play is around actual events that took place in the person’s life. This means that such a film portrays real characters of not just the main protagonist but also others who were part of his or her life. The names are real, the time lines are accurate and reflect true events. Examples of biopics are Richard Attenborough’s Gandhi and in the recent past M.S.Dhoni based on the popular cricketer.

In a biopic, it is assumed that the makers have done enough research to portray true events based on the individual’s life and therefore must be ready for factual scrutiny. There is little or no room for creative liberties on facts that matter. Even here, based on real life incidents, film makers do resort to a bit of dramatization for effect.

On the other hand, a film like Soorarai Pottru is NOT a biopic on Captain Gopinath. It is a film that is based on his life as depicted in his book – Simply Fly. That’s all. Like how, many films are based on novels, this one is based on this book. Having bought the filming rights for the book, the makers do have the right to exercise their creative liberties to flesh out a script that can be made as interesting as possible.

Cinema is commerce. Film making apart from being an individual’s artistic pursuit, it is also business. It is an industry where there is investment and Returns On Investment. So, naturally the makers would like their films to get a reach that is as wide as possible and make them blockbusters. In that pursuit, if showcasing the protagonist to be from an under privileged class makes it more dramatic and more relatable to a wider audience, I don’t see anything wrong. Again my point is, this is justified if the film is not a biopic and is just based on some one’s life. Mani Ratnam’s Guru is loosely based on or inspired by the life of Dhirubhai Ambani but it is not a biopic on Dhirubhai. And hence we saw the many deviations and added drama in the script.

Recently, there was a Hindi film by name – Gunjan Saxena – The Kargil Girl that was released and had its own share of controversies. This film is based on the real life of Gunjan Saxena an Ex-IAF pilot. Here the problem was, the makers while calling it a biopic took too much creative liberties whereby the IAF was shown in poor light. The film also was not factual in its depiction in many aspects. So, the panning of the film was justified.  The case of Soorarai Pottru is different from Gunjan Saxena in my opinion.

Inserting a card that the film is inspired by true events and any resemblance to real life characters is purely coincidental is the maker’s way of taking anticipatory bail from probable trolling.  But, even that didn’t help in the case of Soorarai Pottru.  The makers over marketed the Captain Gopinath aspect while they completely changed the story. I also feel that they should not have used the brand ‘Air Deccan’ in the film.  But for these small issues, I don’t think the outrage over the film by section of the audience over twisting the facts regarding Captain Gopinath when it is not a biopic, is justified. Soorarai Pottru is the story of Nedumaaran Rajangam BASED on the life of Captain Gopinath and NOT the story of Captain Gopinath himself. And that’s a huge difference.

Post script: Captain Gopinath himself watched the film and he seemingly did not have any problem in the way the film has come out.

Pic Courtesy: Times of India

12 thoughts on “True Biopic Vs Inspired by

  1. Annada says:

    Hello,
    Nice post! I agree with you about the difference between biopic and based on definition. But isn’t it mere semantics? Isn’t this a license to change facts to suit your agenda and still take advantage of the connection to & popularity of the real life character? I do have a problem when film makers take creative freedom in order to reinforce stereotypes and take the easy way out. Why did this director change the main character’s caste? Just to pander to strongly held beliefs & prejudices? I have no issues with taking creative freedom but when it is done for a vested interest, it does not appeal to me as a viewer. The director who does this kind of hatchery & hackery in the worst possible way is Sanjay Leela Bhansali. My rant for the day 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi Andy, Thanks for the feedback and I appreciate it.
      I get where you are coming from. At times, certain aspects of a celebrity’s life are interesting while other may not be. So the route chosen is to make it not as a True Biopic but “based on” where you don’t use the real names and other real characters and show only those interesting aspects. Here, you get to do whatever you want. In this film, the makers have just taken the gist of Gopinath’s life and woven a story of an underdog realising his dream against all odds. Much of it is fictionalised. As I said, they could have avoided using the same Air Deccan.
      Sanjay Leela Bhansali – I agree is a different issue. He made a movie on a real life character and there he needs to get his facts correct.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Rishya Shringa says:

    Sir, it is good news that there is no slighting of Captain Gopinth’s social background, in the movie. Good news.

    In your article, instead of the words ‘caste’ and again ‘upper caste’ , judicious words could have been chosen, since that is the long term agenda.

    Yes, of course Captain Gopinth could have been portrayed as coming from a family of ‘orthodox religious’ or ‘college educated’ or ‘salaried income’ or ‘urbanized family’ people etc.

    Thought provoking write up and shall assuage the individuals disappointed about the artificial portrayal of his family. Thank you sir

    Liked by 3 people

  3. Ajit Alexander says:

    Good post, Anand. Was it a biopic or is that the perception meant to be portrayed by the director? Sometimes a script could be just for the greater audience and as rightly pointed, for commercial gain. Having said that, creative liberties must be curtailed to depict the correct perspective!
    The moot point is….Is it worth the watch??

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Venkataraman says:

    As a person eagerly waiting for deepawali release film, it is not surprise SP is in “far below expectation level “only because the film is made and released during Corona virus out break.We need more masala, more jigna works, and lot more kavarchi expected in so called Deepawali release films.This is basic funda/
    Formula followed from our child hood days.For sure we have to accept the courage of the film makers to release the films during deepawali.Filmed more unrealistic way and logic is completely missing.no clue how the hero brings such huge money and answer for this question answered it is collected from the contribution of poorest of poor no ipod nothing. Totally unrealistic movie feeling waste of time in watching. No motivation created

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Whatever be the controversies, its a well made film which depicts the extent to which established players in the market go to crush a new idea, upstart. They want to maintain the the status quo and not permit new ideas to find its true place.
    Suriya is in a very different sober role unlike his recent roles and has done a great job in enacting the role.
    I really enjoyed watching the movie, though the end was a bit abrupt.
    I do not see the need for bringing the caste angle to the movie. Its totally meaningless and we seem to be hung up on comparing everything with respect to caste or religion. Hopefully we grow out of this compulsion in our life time !!

    Liked by 2 people

  6. Mani says:

    Good analysis as always.. considering it is a very good storyline it could have been much better. It was also too intense and ended abruptly. Agree 100% on the community positioning and use of ” Deccan Air ” Name.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s