If the alleged gang rape and subsequent murder of a young girl in Hathras, UP was not terrible enough, the post death handling of the situation by the UP Police was even more horrendous. It is still bewildering, that someone suggested or ordered a midnight funeral for a murdered victim by the police instead of handing over the body to the parents!
If that was in Hathras, UP, can anyone forget what happened in Sathankulam in Tamil Nadu, few months ago? In a bizarre case, a father and son duo were beaten to death under custody in Sathankulam police station. For what? For apparently violating lockdown rules!
Last year, in Hyderabad, the police killed the suspects involved in rape and killing of a vet in an early morning encounter which seemed like a scene lifted straight out of a Rohit Shetty (Hindi) or a Hari (Tamil/Telugu) film!
Add to this, the Sushant Singh Rajput case which was hogging media headlines till recently where the police of one state has been in logger heads with another.
Welcome to Singhamisation of Indian police. What is common in all these and more is the crying need for police reforms in India, a long neglected issue by any government of the day.
In our country, the commentariat often talks of the demand for reforms of all types – Economic reforms, labour reforms, judicial reforms, education reforms and so on. But seldom do we get to see the demand of police reforms in the same intensity. And I have always wondered why. As per a data point, roughly 9% of GDP is lost every year on account of poor law and order! And if you remember, GST as a tax reform was introduced because it was believed that it will improve the GDP by up to 3%! And here we are talking about three times that!
In India, maintenance of law and order hangs in between the clichés of “Law and Order is a State subject” and “Law will take its own course”! Law and Order which is one of the deliverables of the police is a state subject. States are run not just by ruling party at the centre. Few states are under the main opposition party, few by smaller opposition parties and many are ruled by regional parties. This situation exists at any given point in time. So, every party worth its salt has a stake in maintaining law and order and therefore interest in keeping the police under its thumbs.
I really don’t know when the last time a government seriously intended to initiate police reforms in the country. Even the Supreme Court directive of implementing the Prakash Singh recommendations in Prakash Singh Vs Union of India case in 2006 I believe has not been heeded to. The fact is no Indian state has fully complied with the recommendations. In irony we can say that police reforms is one subject in which all political parties are on the same page!
I believe that the cornerstone of any police reform needs to be “Independence” and “no Interference”. Unfortunately, the institution of police has been used by the ruling class as an instrument of exercising power and control. So much so that in any government the Home Minister, under whom law and order and therefore the police comes, becomes the De facto No. 2. Not the finance minister or the minister holding any other economic portfolio. The big question is, will any party coming to power would ever give up on keeping the police under their thumb? If our armed forces can be reasonably independent though reporting to a civilian government, why not the police?
The next key focus in police reforms I believe, must be around recruitment, training and compensation. We must not forget that people in the police force have not been dropped from heaven. They are all from the same society as we are. And they read the same WhatsApp forwards as we do. So their world view is shaped and influenced in the same manner as ordinary people. And hence they have their own biases. We saw how this kind of biases come in the way of effective policing even in a developed and mature society like America. I am talking about the death of George Floyd in Minneapolis when a police man was kneeling on Floyd’s neck for nine minutes even when Floyd was pleading for his life. The key is proper recruitment and training where one’s personal biases do not come in the way while discharging public duty.
Though policing is a highly stressful and high pressure job in India, the police are inadequately compensated. And that’s a major reason for not being able to attract bright people to join the force. Adequate and attractive compensation will also reduce the menace of corruption that exists even at low levels. So, the combination of reformed recruitment, proper training and attractive remuneration will go a long way in the police discharging their duties in a more professional way.
Coming back to Singhamisation of police, whether films depict life or life follows films is an unending debate. The reality could be a mix of both. If you see Indian films, there was a time long ago, when they usually featured bumbling cops who will reach the scene at the end when everything was over. Then there was a phase where cops were usually of the corrupt variety who will be siding the villains. Presently it is the Singham era, where cops are this macho super heroes and “Naan Police illa, porukki” types. They deliver justice in their own way and if that means taking law in their own hands, so be it.
And this is what we see in real life as well which is what I call the Singhamisation of the police. Incidentally, the common man in the street who is just interested in timely delivery of justice and not necessarily in the method, loves this. But the point is, if we have to prevent another Hathras or a Sathankulam, police reforms is the need of the hour and not Singhamisation.
Incidentally, Prime Minister Narendra Modi while addressing a bunch of IPS probationers recently, told them not to be influenced by films like Singham. After having initiated bold reforms in agriculture and labour, the time has come for Modi to take up police reforms as well. Then he doesn’t have to worry about Singhamisation of police!
6 thoughts on “The “Singhamisation” of police!”
Even Britishers have used Police force for their purpose. The Police merely inform the new ruler taking charge that they are ready for service. However their own regular agenda goes on , since the lower ranks and the accused are all from almost similar economic strata. The encounters were glorified since forty years. The consumerism is so much on raise , the remuneration will not prevent corruption. PM has to be given reference here is status-quo.
“Singhamisation “, a word tells all. Sir, please write often.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you sir for the views. Appreciate your feedback as usual.
Typical Indian scenario is discussed related to Police.One thing to be understood Police in India are under the direct control of ruling party.
We saw recently the arrogant activities of US police against blacks.This also needs singamisation
On the other hand we shall see in other countries like UK or UAE,ethical behaviour of leaders who are controlling the police, one cannot find such scenes as depicted above.Meaning if the leading is good,police feel proud of being police.If the system is wrong,police frustrated,unable to differentiate between right and wrong
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Venkat for the comment! What you have said is absolutely true.
Good one Anand. You picked up a topic which requires utmost importance in the current scenario. Reforms in police force is definitely long overdue
One thing, which is often, failed to get adequately highlighted is the provocation and the attacks Indian police face. Cops are attacked, brutally too, cops vehicles set ablaze, police stations vandalised n torched. I seriously doubt if these things happen frequently anywhere in the world. Physical attack on police is a serious offence and mostly people won’t have the audacity to touch a cop in many countries
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Mukund, I agree with you on the provocation and hardships police face and where they are advised restraint. Non interference is the key to police reforms and the police must be given a free hand within the law to deal with these kind of incidents.
Thanks for the comment and feedback.