For the past few weeks or so, I am certain that only one question is uppermost in the minds of most Indians. And that is not “Who will become the next Prime Minister”? But it is – “Will Narendra Modi continue as the next Prime Minister?” Everything else doesn’t seem to matter so much. As we near the counting day which is still couple of weeks away, the excitement and the suspense is heightening. The excruciatingly long drawn poll schedule extended over some 7 phases has only added to the nervous excitement of most Indians.
This is manifesting across India in offices, in nukkad tea shops, in local trains, in parties, in cabs and most of all in WhatsApp groups where the hotly discussed topic in this hot summer is if Modi will get a second term. For one who has been keenly following Indian politics for more than more than three decades, I don’t remember a previous time when one person captured the imagination of people the way Modi has now. And capturing the imagination in both extreme ways. It’s either you love him or you loathe him.
With the ban on opinion polls and exit polls when the poll process is underway, it is now left to individuals to speculate on what is going to happen. As the election progresses phase wise, we find the whole media caravan moving along with ground reports where star anchors, editors, reporters and other sundry journalists try to decipher how the wind is blowing!
In all these “ground reports” which are based on hopefully random conversations, I do feel that we end up hearing what we want to hear! So if the ground report is from a Modi follower, then it is in full some praise of Modi for the work he had done in the past 4 years in terms of pucca houses, roads, toilets…! And if the report is from a Modi hater, then it will be critiquing Modi for doing nothing. And believe you me, the reports could be from the same towns/villages!
And in an effort to play safe, most of the ground reports by star anchors and editors have ended up saying
“There is no Modi wave but there is an undercurrent!”
“There is dissatisfaction for Modi but no hate!”
“People are vocally in support of Modi but the silent majority would decide his fate”
And so on!
In putting out these ground reports, will common people be left behind? So, empowered by the powerful vehicle called the “Social Media”, we also have ground reports of “People like Us”! We also give our conclusions based on random chats with Taxi drivers, maid servants, Chowkidars, Doodhwalas and so on.
After the round of ground reports we will be fed with a surfeit of exit polls, come the May 19th. In India we have seen that even pollsters tend to see what they want to see. In India now, opinion polls, exit polls and psephology have become major revenue streams for channels and pollsters thanks to the multiplicity of national and regional news channels. Though forecasting is considered a science we have seen that the forecast results swing from one end to another and rarely do we see a common band making it a perfect modern art! In modern art you see what you want to see!! Ergo, pollsters and the polling company’s own bias come to play in the prediction. In addition to bhakts, bhakt reporters, bhakt anchors, bhakt channels, welcome to world of bhakt pollsters. Would you believe if I say that for one of the state elections, one polling company had two different exit poll results for two different channels!
Dr. Prannoy Roy of NDTV who can be credited for introducing the concept of opinion polls, exit polls and psephology in general to Indians, in his latest book – The Verdict, covers the aspect of the complexity in Indian elections in great detail. No wonder opinion polls and exit polls and the much touted ground reports have more often than not missed the mark when the actual results are out. Hence in a diverse, pluralistic country like India where nothing is common and for every aspect, the opposite is equally true, if a forecast is correct, it could only be a stroke of luck! And that’s why I feel venturing out to hazard a guess on any election outcome in India and in particular the ongoing Lok Sabha polls is fraught with high risks of getting it all wrong!
As experts do always, it is wiser and certainly easier to attach logical explanations to the results as they unfold on the 23rd. Hence I am curbing my instincts to join the ground reports band wagon. And will stick to a detailed blog post to give my take on the results post 23rd rather than sticking my neck out today!! Having said that, I go back to where I started. No leader has taken the mind share of Indians as much as Modi in the recent times. When “mood of the nation” poll has become “Modi of the nation poll”, he must be doing something right, right? All of it cannot be just “Marketing” as some rue! After all great marketing has not saved a bad product in history! Or has it? Is Trump winning again? 🙂 🙂
Picture courtesy: India Today
9 thoughts on “Mood (di) of the Nation poll!”
I liked your wise conclusion.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Babu! Appreciate your comment!
You have articulated the mind of an urban citizen very aptly.
I have seen so many general elections. This is the first time where people are debating about the leader of the nation based on an individual rather than a party. India needs this. We need a strong leader as a PM rather than a person announced by the Federation if multiple parties who have selfish agenda based on linguistic /regional focus , caste.
We should continue this trend to decide the ruling party based on its leader rather than anything else .
I am not in favour of any party. But I badly look forward to having a PM who has guts,spine and willing to take tough decisions.india needs that person now.
Well done Rasa
Thanks and regards
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Jani, Thank you for your detailed views and feedback! I agree with most of what you are saying! Lets see how things unfold on the 23rd May!
Excellent Anand. Well articulated…👌
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well covered blog n u have wisely directed your readers to next blog post 23 May 😊😊
Jokes apart, it’s true that this election turning out to be an unipolar (if I may say so) contest, but to ponder whether it’s good or bad is for another day
I have a gut feeling that this election will throw a major surprise. Will look forward to ur blog post-23rd May for the insight 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you Mukund! Will the surprise going to be pleasant or otherwise is the 7 crore question!
It’s onerous to find knowledgeable folks on this subject, however you sound like you recognize what you’re speaking about! Thanks